Prime Video
Showrunner Eric Kripke recently confirmedThe Boyswill end in season 5 . The proclamation came only a few twenty-four hours after speculation emerged aboutthe show possibly hold up beyondits initial five - season plan , specially considering the highly - anticipate season 4 returns this week to strong reviews and unbelievable hype from audience .
The thing is , it makes sentience to endThe Boyswith season 5 — it also makes no sense to endThe Boyswith time of year 5 . The show is undisputedly the crown gem of Amazon Prime Video , earn the type of vista and give the kind of treatment few television project can . In short , The Boysis a true phenomenon , the ilk of which we are getting less used to . Only a few other boob tube projects can compare toThe boy ‘ influence on pop culture — for certain none from Prime Video . So , while ending a show in the showrunner ’s full term will always be a serious thing , a unattackable guinea pig can be made for whyThe Boysshould continue beyond its five - season bow , albeit with some change .
Prime Video
Leave while you’re on top?
The Boyshas been a very stiff performer for Amazon , increase in relevance and acclamation with each time of year , even if it arguably top out with its Emmy - nominated second season . However , at least in terms of cultural relevancy , The Boyshas never been higher . It all come back to its delightfully insurgent mental attitude , true coolheaded premiss , and a glorious supporting players who very distinctly hump what they ’re doing . The Boyshas smashing characters , snappy dialog , quite decent visual effects , thrilling action , and a refreshing , ego - cognisant tone that makes it enjoyable yet disruptive . The show undertake real - life issues with wicked zestfulness , gleefully paint the middle finger to many penis of its consultation , who are often in on the laugh .
From a line linear perspective , it makes no signified to endThe Boyswith time of year 5.Reviews are strong , evaluation are even stronger , and the show is still fresh and sympathetic . It trends on social media , meet meaning reporting , and , most importantly , remains among the few superhero franchises that are still systematically supported by spectator , a status that is now more precious amidthe seeming fall of the MCU . Why end a sure hit when it could perfectly go on for at least two more seasons ?
Yes , Amazon Prime is alreadydeveloping several spinoffs , include one set in Mexico , plus a second season ofthe flawed but entertainingGen Vand more unannounced labor . But the trouble with spinoffs is that they ’re not the original , and if there ’s something we ’re seeing right now , it ’s that people do n’t of necessity desire to see stuff without the theatrical role they like . Do n’t make aSpider - Man movie without Spider - Man ; do n’t make aMad Max movie without Max . These projects will all be inevitably compared to the original , and many will not rise to the challenge .
In many ways , it feels like these spinoffs are being set up to fail . After all , if you want more ofThe Boys , just do more ofThe Boys . The solution is very bare , especially considering the show ’s premiss is capable of fend for more seasons . The actors are all reserve , if not exactly busy , so they should all agree to a pair more . Crucially , The Boyshasn’t overextended its welcome , arguably the most crucial aspect in deciding whether to terminate a beloved show in its prime .
It’s all about the bad guy
I am a supporter of Lord being allow to fulfill their visual sense as they see fit . If the programme forThe Boyswas always a five - season running , then more mightiness to Kripke and Amazon for stupefy to it . However , their willingness to keep the enfranchisement going via spinoffs confirm their desire to stay in this frail world . Perhaps they fearThe Boysis becoming too safe or formulaic . Maybe they dread the show ’s political comment might alien what has , so far , been a very loyal hearing .
The latter is more improbable , so permit ’s focalise on the former . Yes , The Boysis becoming passably secure due to its loyalty to Antony Starr ’s Homelander . The show ’s breakout graphic symbol and de - facto star , Homelander is the placard child for unbalance superheroes , reign supreme over the the like of Omni - Man andthe more divisive evil Superman . However , Homelander ’s level — which in more way than one isThe Boys ‘ story — has become repetitive . Every time of year precede to a climactic struggle against the vicious superhero , which he barely escapes , only to return more powerful than before , thus set the stage for the next season . After three years , the shtick has develop timeworn .
The Boys ‘ decision to terminate in time of year 5 comes , I think , largely from the desire to let go of Homelander without necessarily letting go of him . The estimate of sideline , let alone pour down , Homelander might seem unthinkable , but it makes perfect sentiency forThe Boys ‘ famously insurgent nature . Moreover , that ’s on the nose what happens in the comic Bible series , where he dies rather anti - climactically before Billy Butcher assumes the role of the main antagonist for the remainder issue .
Thus , The Boyshas two options : It cango theGame of Thronesrouteand kill Homelanderandestablish Butcher as the final villain in season 5 ( because it ’s unlikely it will do so in season 4 ) , or it can take its time , terminal season 5 with Homelander ’s death , and then allow Butcher to become the villain in a likely season 6 . Between those two choice , it ’s no surprise I , and surely many other fans , opt the latter . The show has n’t done a dandy job of found Butcher as a strong enough competition for villainy to pull in it off in one season , peculiarly with Homelander ’s shadow loom so large .
Evolve or die
The Boysis at a pivotal moment , not only as a show but , more importantly , as a franchise . It can either endure alongside the all - time great or see its bequest stained by a mystify end followed by less and countless spinoffs . Just look atHouse of the Dragon , a starring show that still has a hard time get away from underGame of Thrones ‘ shadow .
If Amazon still want to be in theBoysbusiness , it should focus on keeping the show relevant and applaud for a few more yr . Spinoffs are serious for support , but the independent result should last out the same . Amazon has a salutary affair going on withThe Boys , but it can easily ruin it by reach the incorrect decision . If ending in time of year 5 makes the most sense , then go for it . However , the signs all point to a story that could benefit from more place to respire . Major TV appearance have already been bankrupt by their despair to get to the finish telephone line ; do n’t make that fault , Amazon .
The Boysis available tostream on Amazon Prime Video .
